For Canadian owner-led companies
Expanding Your Canadian Business to the US
Illuminous Accounting is based in Surrey and serves clients across Greater Vancouver and remotely. Choose the right US structure, set up books and payroll that work in both countries, and know every first-year filing before it is due. Gurleen Kaur, CPA licensed in British Columbia and Washington State, prepares the Canadian T2 and the US returns, such as Form 1120, Form 5472 or Form 1065, as relevant.
Quick answer
What does a Canadian company need to expand into the US?
First, a structure decision: operate as a branch of the Canadian company, which files Form 1120-F, or form a US subsidiary, which files Form 1120. Under IRS Tax Treaty Table 1, dividends from a US subsidiary to a Canadian parent generally owning 10% or more of the votes are taxed at a 5% treaty rate. Then an EIN, US banking, books that consolidate with the Canadian company, documented intercompany terms, payroll and state registrations. In Canada, a US subsidiary usually means filing Form T1134 each year. The right answer depends on your liability, people, profits and plans to bring money home.
Branch, subsidiary or LLC: side by side
Each cell links to the IRS, CRA or FinCEN source. Treaty rates require eligibility and documentation.
| US branch | US subsidiary (C corporation) | US LLC owned by the Canadian company | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | The Canadian company does business in the US directly | A separate US corporation owned by the Canadian company | A US LLC owned by the Canadian company |
| Main US return | Form 1120-F (instructions) | Form 1120 at the 21% federal rate, plus state (instructions) | Disregarded by default: treated like a branch, and the LLC files a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472 (instructions) |
| Profits back to Canada | Branch profits tax, generally at the treaty direct dividend rate (Table 1, note aaa) | Dividends: 5% treaty rate for a parent generally owning 10% or more of the votes, 15% otherwise (Table 1) | As for a branch, because the US looks through the LLC |
| FinCEN BOI | A Canadian company registered to do business in a US state is still a reporting company (FinCEN) | US-formed companies are currently exempt | US-formed companies are currently exempt |
| Canadian side | Profits taxed in Canada with foreign tax credit rules | Foreign affiliate: Form T1134 within 10 months (CRA); T106 where required | Canada generally treats the LLC as a corporation and foreign affiliate |
| Common fit | Testing the market with limited US presence | Hiring, leasing or selling at scale in the US | Rarely the best fit; see our LLC guide |
A Canadian company that claims it has no US permanent establishment still generally files Form 1120-F to show the treaty exemption, and discloses the position on Form 8833. Read more about the US LLC double-tax risk for Canadians.
How can a Canadian company own a US business? The main options
The table above compares the first three side by side. Here is what each means in practice: what you file, how profits come home and who it usually suits.
1. The Canadian company operates in the US directly (a branch)
US: under Article VII of the treaty, business profits are taxable in the US only if they are attributable to a US permanent establishment (treaty). A Canadian company doing business in the US generally files Form 1120-F, and if it claims there is no permanent establishment it still generally files, disclosing the position on Form 8833. File on time: the Form 1120-F instructions say a return filed more than 18 months after its due date generally loses the right to deductions and credits. Profits home: the branch profits tax is limited to 5% under Article X(6), after a C$500,000 exemption. Canada: the Canadian company reports the income on its T2, with foreign tax credit rules. Usually suits: testing the market with limited US presence.
2. A US corporation owned by the Canadian company (a subsidiary)
US: Form 1120. As a 25% foreign-owned corporation it also files Form 5472, a separate one for each related party it had reportable transactions with (Form 5472 instructions), the BE-13 report within 45 days if it is new (BE-13), and state returns where it does business. Canada: the parent files its T2, Form T1134 for its foreign affiliate within 10 months of its year end (CRA), and Form T106 when its non-arm's length transactions with non-residents exceed C$1,000,000 in the year (s.233.1). Profits home: US tax on dividends is limited to 5% under Article X(2)(a) when the parent owns at least 10% of the voting stock. The US company withholds and reports it (Form 1042 and 1042-S) and keeps the parent's Form W-8BEN-E. In Canada, the parent can deduct the part of a dividend paid out of the affiliate's exempt surplus (s.113(1)), a term defined by regulation. Interest paid to the parent is taxable only in Canada under Article XI(1). Usually suits: hiring, leasing or selling at scale in the US.
3. A US LLC owned by the Canadian company
US: a single-member LLC is disregarded by default, so the Canadian company is treated as doing business in the US itself, as in option 1, and the LLC files a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472. Canada: the LLC is generally treated as a corporation and a foreign affiliate. Article IV(7) of the treaty says income is not considered derived by a resident in some cases where the two countries treat the entity differently, which can take away treaty rates. The fix some owners use: the LLC can elect to be taxed as a corporation on Form 8832, and the US then treats it like option 2. Usually suits: rarely the first choice for a Canadian company. See US LLCs for Canadians and, for property, Canadians buying US real estate.
4. You own the US company personally, not through your Canadian company
The rules change: dividends to an individual are taxed in the US at up to 15% under the treaty (Table 1), the income lands on your personal T1, and Canadian foreign reporting such as T1134 or T1135 depends on how much you own. This is a different decision; see US LLCs for Canadians.
What the expansion package includes
A fixed-fee project covering structure, setup and year one. Ongoing bookkeeping and annual filings continue under a separate monthly engagement if you want them.
Structure decision
Branch, US subsidiary or another structure, compared on your expected profits, people and plans to bring money home.
Entity and EIN
Formation coordination with your lawyer, EIN application for a foreign-owned company (Form SS-4) and US banking documents. The BE-13 report to the Commerce Department, due within 45 days of forming the US subsidiary (see BE-13).
Books built for two countries
US chart of accounts, monthly close process and reporting that consolidates with the Canadian company.
Intercompany terms
Management fees, loans, cost sharing and sales between the companies, documented on arm's-length terms in both countries.
People and payroll
Employee versus contractor review, payroll provider setup coordination and the federal filings in Publication 15, such as Form 941 and Form W-2.
States and sales tax
State registrations, state income tax exposure and sales tax registration review for the states you sell into.
First-year filing calendar
Every US and Canadian deadline for year one in one calendar: BE-13, Form 1120 or 1120-F, Form 5472, state returns, payroll filings, T1134 and T106.
How it works
- Request a quote. Your plans, timeline and current structure.
- Scoping and fixed fee. We confirm what the project covers and send a written scope.
- Structure memo. Branch versus subsidiary compared on your numbers, coordinated with your lawyer.
- Setup. EIN, books, intercompany terms, payroll and state registrations.
- Year-one calendar. Every US and Canadian deadline, owned and tracked.
Common mistakes Canadian owners make with a US company
- Choosing an LLC to avoid US tax. The US looks through a single-member LLC, so the Canadian company is taxed in the US anyway, while Canada treats the LLC as a corporation, a mismatch that can cost treaty rates.
- Missing Form 5472. The penalty is US$25,000 per form, and each related party with reportable transactions needs its own form (IRS).
- Missing T1134 or T106. Late information returns carry a penalty of the greater of $100 and $25 a day for up to 100 days under s.162(7) (Income Tax Act).
- No intercompany agreements. Management fees, loans and cost sharing need arm's-length terms in writing, because both the IRS (section 482) and the CRA (s.247) can adjust them.
- Running the US company entirely from Canada. The CRA may treat it as resident in Canada (see company residence below), and US activity can create a permanent establishment.
- Paying US costs from the Canadian company without recording it. Without a written loan or capital record, it is hard to support how the money is treated in either country.
- Lending from the US company to the Canadian parent. A loan from a foreign affiliate can be included in the parent's income under s.90(6) unless an exception applies (Income Tax Act).
- Forming in Wyoming or Delaware but operating somewhere else. The state where you actually do business has its own registration and tax rules (choosing a state).
- Forgetting the BE-13. A new US business owned by a foreign company is reported to the Commerce Department within 45 days (BE-13).
- Paying dividends with no withholding. The US company is the withholding agent and reports the payment on Forms 1042 and 1042-S (Form 1042).
Every year after setup: a US subsidiary of a Canadian company
| United States | Canada |
|---|---|
| Form 1120 | T2 for the Canadian parent |
| Form 5472, one per related party with reportable transactions | T1134 for the foreign affiliate, within 10 months of year end |
| State returns where the company does business | T106 when non-arm's length transactions with non-residents exceed C$1,000,000 |
| Forms 1042 and 1042-S if it pays dividends or other amounts to the parent | Dividends received, and the exempt surplus records behind them |
Gurleen Kaur, CPA (BC and Washington) prepares both sides. Request a Quote
Could the CRA treat your US company as resident in Canada?
Forming a company in the US does not by itself settle where it is resident for Canadian tax. The CRA says a company is generally resident where its central management and control is exercised, which is usually where its board meets (CRA: Residency of a corporation). The CRA treats a US LLC as a corporation, so the same question can arise for an LLC. If the people making the real decisions do so from Canada, the CRA may treat the US company as resident in Canada.
This matters because a company resident in both countries can face tax and filings in both. The CRA notes that a treaty overrides the Income Tax Act when a corporation is considered resident in more than one country, so the treaty has to be checked. Under Article IV of the Canada-US treaty, a company created under the laws of only one of the two countries is generally treated as resident of that country (Article IV(3)). That rule is for a company resident in both countries, and a single-member LLC that the IRS ignores is not itself taxed by the US, so do not assume the rule helps an LLC.
Who will make the decisions, and from where, is one of the points we review with you before setup, because it is easier to plan than to correct later. The result depends on your facts.
Who this is for
- Canadian corporations opening a US office, warehouse or sales team
- Canadian companies hiring their first US employee
- Founders moving to the US on an E-2 visa while keeping a Canadian company
- Owner-led businesses that already sell into the US and need to check whether they owe US filings
US expansion questions
Should my Canadian company open a US branch or a US subsidiary?
It depends on liability, how profits will come back to Canada, who will own the US business and how much US activity you expect. A branch means the Canadian company itself files a US return (Form 1120-F) and may owe branch profits tax. A US subsidiary is a separate US corporation that files Form 1120, with treaty withholding on dividends paid to the Canadian parent. We compare both on your numbers before anything is formed.
Does a Canadian company selling into the US have to file a US return?
If it is engaged in a trade or business in the United States, the IRS Form 1120-F instructions say it must file Form 1120-F, even when that income is exempt under a tax treaty. A company claiming treaty protection because it has no US permanent establishment generally files to show the exemption and discloses the position on Form 8833.
What US tax applies to dividends from a US subsidiary to its Canadian parent?
IRS Tax Treaty Table 1 lists a 5% direct dividend rate for Canada, which generally applies to a parent corporation owning at least 10% of the voting stock, and a 15% general rate. Treaty eligibility conditions apply, and the parent must document its treaty claim to the payer.
Is a US LLC a good choice for a Canadian company?
Often not. By default the US treats a single-member LLC as disregarded, so a Canadian company owning one is treated as doing business in the US directly and the LLC still files a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472. Canada generally treats the LLC as a corporation. Read our US LLC guide before forming one.
What changes on the Canadian side when we open a US subsidiary?
The US subsidiary is usually a foreign affiliate of the Canadian parent, so the parent files Form T1134 with the CRA within 10 months of its year end for tax years beginning after 2020. Transactions with the subsidiary, such as management fees, loans or sales, may also need Form T106 reporting. Intercompany pricing should be documented on arm's-length terms in both countries.
Do we need to register for US sales tax?
There is no US federal sales tax, but each state sets its own registration rules, including thresholds based on sales into the state. We review where you sell and coordinate registrations with the states that apply.
How much does the expansion package cost?
The fee is fixed after we review your structure and documents. It depends on the structure, the number of states, whether you hire US employees and how much intercompany activity there will be. Ongoing monthly bookkeeping and annual filings are quoted separately.
Sources
US rules link to the IRS, Canadian rules to the CRA and beneficial ownership rules to FinCEN. We re-check them before each engagement.
- IRS: Instructions for Form 1120-F (foreign corporations)
- IRS: Instructions for Form 1120
- IRS: Instructions for Form 5472
- IRS: Tax Treaty Table 1 (withholding rates by country)
- IRS: About Form 8833 (treaty-based return position)
- IRS: United States income tax treaties A to Z
- IRS Publication 15, Employer's Tax Guide
- IRS: Instructions for Form SS-4 (EIN)
- CRA: Information returns relating to foreign affiliates (T1134)
- CRA: Form T106, non-arm's length transactions with non-residents
- Department of Finance Canada: Canada-US Tax Convention, consolidated (Articles IV, VII, X and XI)
- IRS: About Form 8832, Entity Classification Election
- Justice Laws: Income Tax Act s.113 (dividends from a foreign affiliate)
- Justice Laws: Income Tax Act s.90 (loans from a foreign affiliate)
- Justice Laws: Income Tax Act s.162 (penalties)
- Justice Laws: Income Tax Act s.233.1 (T106 threshold)
- Justice Laws: Income Tax Act s.247 (transfer pricing)
- US Code: 26 U.S.C. 482 (allocation between related organizations)
- FinCEN: Beneficial ownership information reporting
Prepared by Illuminous Accounting · Sources checked November 5, 2026. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice for your situation.
Plan your US expansion with a CPA licensed on both sides
Tell us your situation in a few lines. We confirm whether we can help, what records matter and the next step. Substantive advice begins under a paid diagnostic or signed engagement.
Prepared and signed by a licensed US CPA who can represent you before the IRS. Verify Gurleen Kaur's Washington licence (#41150) on CPAverify