For Canadian residents who own or plan a US LLC, last checked October 30, 2026
US LLC for Canadian Residents: The Tax Mismatch and How to Handle It
The IRS looks through a single-member LLC to its owner. The CRA treats the same LLC as a corporation. Here is what that does to your tax, which forms each country expects, and the options owners use, each with the official source. Gurleen Kaur, CPA, prepares both sides: the US returns and the Canadian T1 and T2.
Quick answer
Should a Canadian resident use a US LLC?
Usually only with planning. The IRS treats a single-member LLC as part of its owner (IRS), while the CRA treats a US LLC as a corporation (US Treasury Technical Explanation). So the US can tax you on the profit as it is earned while Canada taxes you later, when the LLC pays you, and the foreign tax credit may not line up. You also file Form 5472 with the IRS every year, and T1134 with the CRA because the LLC is a foreign affiliate. Common fixes are a Form 8832 corporate election, a US corporation, or closing the LLC.
The mismatch in one table
| Question | IRS (United States) | CRA (Canada) |
|---|---|---|
| What is the LLC? | A single-member LLC is disregarded; a multi-member LLC is a partnership, unless it elects to be a corporation on Form 8832 (Form 8832) | A corporation and a taxpayer in its own right (Treasury Technical Explanation) |
| Who is taxed on the profit? | You, the owner, as the LLC earns it (if it is US business income) | The LLC is the visible taxpayer; you are generally taxed when it pays you, as income from a foreign corporation, unless foreign affiliate rules tax you earlier |
| What does the owner report each year? | Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 for a foreign-owned single-member LLC (IRS), plus a personal Form 1040-NR if the LLC has US business income | T1134 if the LLC is a foreign affiliate, otherwise T1135 if your foreign property costs more than C$100,000 |
| Result | US tax in the year earned | Canadian tax often in a different year and on a different taxpayer, so the foreign tax credit may not line up |
Canadian forms: T1134 or T1135
Most owners of a wholly owned US LLC file T1134, not T1135. The two do not overlap for the same LLC.
| Form | When it applies to a US LLC | Due |
|---|---|---|
| T1134 | The LLC is your foreign affiliate: you own an equity percentage of at least 1%, and at least 10% together with related persons (Income Tax Act s. 95(1)) | Within 10 months after the end of your taxation year |
| T1135 | Your specified foreign property cost more than C$100,000 at any time in the year. Shares of a foreign affiliate are not specified foreign property, so an LLC reported on T1134 is not reported again on T1135 (Income Tax Act s. 233.3(1)) | With your income tax return (CRA) |
| Penalty for filing late | The greater of c$100 and c$25 a day for up to 100 days (so up to c$2,500) for each late information return | Income Tax Act s. 162(7) |
US filings for the LLC
- Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 every year for a foreign-owned single-member LLC, faxed or mailed, never e-filed (IRS). Extension: Form 7004.
- Form 1040-NR if the LLC has income from a US trade or business. See Form 1040-NR.
- The state annual report and fee; see US LLC annual fees by state.
- BE-13 within 45 days of forming a new LLC; see BE-13 for foreign-owned companies.
Records to keep
- Articles of organization and the operating agreement
- EIN letter and any Form 8832 election
- Bank statements showing money in from you and money paid out to you
- US and Canadian returns already filed, and any IRS or CRA letters
- Exchange rates used for each payment
Options owners review
Options to review with an adviser, not a recommendation for your facts.
- Elect corporate treatment (Form 8832). Both countries then see a corporation. Expect US corporate tax, a full Form 1120 and planning for how profit is paid to you.
- Use a US corporation from the start. For a new US business, a C corporation avoids the classification mismatch. Compare it in our Canada-to-US expansion guide.
- Operate without a US entity. If the work is done in Canada and US rules allow, a Canadian business may contract with US clients directly. A US customer alone does not require a US entity.
- Close the LLC. Closing ends future filings but not past ones. See closing a US LLC properly.
Buying, renting or selling US real estate through an LLC
Many Canadians look at a US LLC to hold US real estate. Before you buy, compare the LLC with owning the property personally or through a corporation, because the mismatch above also applies to rental income and to a sale. See Canadians buying US real estate: should you use an LLC?
- Renting it out: how US rent is taxed for a Canadian owner.
- Florida: how a Florida rental is taxed.
- Selling it: selling US property as a Canadian and FIRPTA withholding.
- Owning it at death: US estate tax for Canadians.
Could the CRA treat your US company as resident in Canada?
Forming a company in the US does not by itself settle where it is resident for Canadian tax. The CRA says a company is generally resident where its central management and control is exercised, which is usually where its board meets (CRA: Residency of a corporation). The CRA treats a US LLC as a corporation, so the same question can arise for an LLC. If the people making the real decisions do so from Canada, the CRA may treat the US company as resident in Canada.
This matters because a company resident in both countries can face tax and filings in both. The CRA notes that a treaty overrides the Income Tax Act when a corporation is considered resident in more than one country, so the treaty has to be checked. Under Article IV of the Canada-US treaty, a company created under the laws of only one of the two countries is generally treated as resident of that country (Article IV(3)). That rule is for a company resident in both countries, and a single-member LLC that the IRS ignores is not itself taxed by the US, so do not assume the rule helps an LLC.
Who will make the decisions, and from where, is one of the points we review with you before setup, because it is easier to plan than to correct later. The result depends on your facts.
Formed the LLC online?
Formation platforms set up the company; most do not file Form 5472, the state report or the Canadian forms. See what formation services don't file, and our annual compliance package if you want every yearly US filing handled.
Common questions
Is a US LLC a good idea for a Canadian resident?
Often not, at least not without planning. The US treats a single-member LLC as part of its owner, while Canada treats it as a corporation. The two countries can then tax the same profit in different years and in different hands, and the foreign tax credit that normally prevents double tax may not match up.
How does Canada tax a US LLC?
The CRA treats a US LLC as a corporation, as the US Treasury's explanation of the 2007 treaty protocol records (Technical Explanation, Article IV(6)). For a Canadian owner, the LLC is a non-resident corporation; payments from it are generally taxed as income from a foreign corporation, and if it is a foreign affiliate, the foreign affiliate and FAPI rules can apply.
Why is there double taxation with a US LLC?
Because the two countries disagree on who earned the income and when. The US taxes the owner on LLC profit as it is earned. Canada generally sees the LLC as the earner and taxes the owner when the money is paid out. A foreign tax credit in Canada is limited to Canadian tax on the same income, so US tax paid in one year may not offset Canadian tax charged on a distribution in another.
Do I file T1134 or T1135 for my US LLC?
T1134 if the LLC is your foreign affiliate, which a wholly owned LLC is: generally you own an equity percentage of at least 1%, and at least 10% together with related persons. T1135 is for specified foreign property costing more than C$100,000, and shares of a foreign affiliate are excluded from it, so you do not report the same LLC on both (Income Tax Act).
When is T1134 due?
Within 10 months after the end of your taxation year, one return for each foreign affiliate (Income Tax Act s. 233.4(4)). The late-filing penalty is the greater of C$100 and C$25 a day for up to 100 days (so up to C$2,500) for each late information return.
Does my US LLC have to file anything with the IRS?
Yes. A single-member LLC wholly owned by a foreign person files Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 every year, even with no income (Form 5472 instructions). The penalty for missing it is US$25,000. See Form 5472 filing.
Can I elect to have my LLC taxed as a corporation in the US?
Yes, on Form 8832. Then both countries treat it as a corporation, which removes the classification mismatch but brings US corporate tax and a full Form 1120. The election generally cannot take effect more than 75 days before or more than 12 months after it is filed, and after a change the LLC generally cannot change again for 60 months (Form 8832 instructions). Electing changes the tax treatment of the LLC's assets, so it is planned before filing.
What are the usual fixes for a Canadian with a US LLC?
There is no single answer, and these are options to review, not advice: elect corporate treatment on Form 8832, operate through a US corporation instead, run the work through a Canadian business without a US entity where US rules allow, or wind the LLC down (closing a US LLC properly). Each changes US filings, Canadian reporting and how profit reaches you.
Does the Canada-US treaty fix the LLC problem?
Not fully. Article IV(6) and IV(7) of the treaty deal with entities that are see-through in one country and not the other, but they decide when treaty benefits apply; they do not make the two countries classify the LLC the same way (treaty text, Technical Explanation).
I already have a US LLC. What should I do first?
Collect the formation documents, any entity elections, the US and Canadian returns filed so far, and the bank statements showing what was paid to you and when. With those, the mismatch, the missed filings and the options can be costed before anything is changed.
Sources
Every rule and figure on this page links to the IRS, CRA or other official source it comes from. Amounts change; we re-check them before each engagement.
- IRS: Single member limited liability companies
- IRS: Form 8832, Entity Classification Election, and instructions
- IRS: Instructions for Form 5472 (foreign-owned US disregarded entities)
- US Treasury: Technical Explanation of the 2007 Protocol to the Canada-US tax treaty (Article IV(6))
- Department of Finance Canada: Canada-US Tax Convention (consolidated)
- CRA: Form T1134, Information return relating to controlled and not-controlled foreign affiliates
- CRA: Questions and answers about Form T1135
- Justice Laws: Income Tax Act, sections 95(1), 233.3 and 233.4
- CRA: Residency of a corporation
Gurleen Kaur, CPA licensed in British Columbia and Washington State. Last updated October 30, 2026. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice for your situation.
Related guides: US-Canada business tax, Form 5472 filing, FBAR vs T1135, Closing a US LLC, LCGE and a US subsidiary, Regulation 105 withholding.
Ask about your US LLC as a Canadian owner
Tell us your situation in a few lines. We confirm whether we can help, what records matter and the next step. Substantive advice begins under a paid diagnostic or signed engagement.
Prepared and signed by a licensed US CPA who can represent you before the IRS. Verify Gurleen Kaur's Washington licence (#41150) on CPAverify