US citizens and green card holders living abroad, done remotely

FEIE vs Foreign Tax Credit for Americans Abroad and in Canada

US citizens living in Canada, Europe or anywhere abroad still file a US return every year, and two tools prevent double tax: the Form 2555 exclusion and the Form 1116 credit. Gurleen Kaur, CPA licensed in British Columbia and Washington State, compares both on your actual numbers before choosing.

Form 2555 exclusionForm 1116 creditJune 15 extensionFBAR and Form 8938
Living in Europe?See US tax for Americans living in Europe.
Want this handled every year?See our yearly US tax package for Americans in Canada.

Quick answer

Should an American in Canada use the FEIE or the foreign tax credit?

It depends on your income and the Canadian tax on it, so both should be run. The foreign earned income exclusion lets a qualifying person exclude up to US$130,000 of foreign earned income for 2025 and US$132,900 for 2026 (IRS), but it covers only earned income, not pensions, interest, dividends or capital gains. The foreign tax credit offsets US tax with Canadian income tax paid on foreign income, and the IRS says the credit is in most cases the better choice. When the Canadian tax on your income is at least as high as the US tax, the credit can often reduce the US tax to nil. Revoking the exclusion also blocks it for five years without IRS approval.

Prepared by Illuminous Accounting · Sources checked October 28, 2026

The two options side by side

Sources: Form 2555 instructions, IRS FEIE amounts, Form 1116 instructions, Publication 514.

FEIE (Form 2555)Foreign tax credit (Form 1116)
What it doesExcludes foreign earned income from US taxable incomeCredits foreign income tax against US tax on foreign source income
LimitUS$130,000 for 2025; US$132,900 for 2026, per qualifying personCredit reduces US tax only on foreign source income; separate calculation for each category of income
Income coveredWages and self-employment income earned abroad onlyEarned and investment income, such as wages, interest, dividends and gains
Unused amountsLostUnused foreign tax carried back 1 year and forward 10 years
Changing your mindAfter revoking, not available for the next 5 tax years without IRS approvalCan choose credit or deduction each year

Qualifying for the exclusion

Your tax home must be in a foreign country, and you must meet one of these tests (Form 2555 instructions):

  • Bona fide residence: a bona fide resident of a foreign country for an uninterrupted period that includes an entire tax year. Americans settled in Canada usually look at this test.
  • Physical presence: present in a foreign country for at least 330 full days during any 12 consecutive months.

Housing: a separate exclusion or deduction covers housing costs above 16% of the maximum exclusion, generally capped at 30% of it (US$39,000 for 2025, US$39,870 for 2026) (IRS, IRS).

Why the credit often wins in Canada

  • The exclusion does not cover pensions, annuities or investment income, so a credit is often still needed for those.
  • Income left after the exclusion is taxed at the higher rates that would apply without it.
  • Under the credit, excess Canadian tax carries forward up to 10 years and can shelter future foreign income.

The exclusion can still suit someone with income taxed lightly in Canada or with a short assignment. That is why we run both.

Deadlines for Americans in Canada

  • Automatic June 15 extension: US citizens and resident aliens who live outside the US and Puerto Rico, with their main place of business or post of duty outside them, get an automatic 2-month extension to June 15. A statement is attached to the return, and interest runs from April 15 on unpaid tax (IRS).
  • FBAR: if your Canadian accounts together exceed US$10,000 at any time in the year, FinCEN Form 114 is due April 15 with an automatic extension to October 15 (IRS).
  • Form 8938: for people living abroad, more than US$200,000 at year end or US$300,000 at any time if unmarried, and US$400,000 or US$600,000 for a joint return (IRS).

More detail: FBAR and FATCA.

Behind on US returns?

Under the IRS Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures, an eligible non-willful filer living abroad files the most recent three years of returns and six years of FBARs, with a certification of non-willful conduct. Compare your options in our streamlined filing guide, or see what you may need to file with the US person in Canada filing checker. We work with Americans across Canada from our Surrey office.

Common questions

What is the foreign earned income exclusion for 2026?

US$132,900 per qualifying person for 2026, up from US$130,000 for 2025, according to the IRS.

Can I use the FEIE on my Canadian pension or investment income?

No. The exclusion covers foreign earned income only. Pensions, annuities, interest, dividends and capital gains are not foreign earned income.

Can I use both the FEIE and the foreign tax credit?

Yes, on different income. You cannot claim a credit for foreign tax on income you excluded, but you can claim it on income the exclusion does not cover.

What happens if I stop using the FEIE?

If you revoke the exclusion, you cannot claim it again for your next 5 tax years without IRS approval.

When is my US return due if I live in Canada?

You get an automatic extension to June 15 if you live and have your main place of business outside the US and Puerto Rico. Interest on unpaid tax still runs from April 15.

Ask which option fits your US return

Tell us your situation in a few lines. We confirm whether we can help, what records matter and the next step. Substantive advice begins under a paid diagnostic or signed engagement.

Prepared and signed by a licensed US CPA who can represent you before the IRS. Verify Gurleen Kaur's Washington licence (#41150) on CPAverify

By submitting, you agree that Illuminous Accounting may use this information to respond to your inquiry. Please do not include account numbers or other sensitive documents. If we work together, documents come in through our secure client portal, never by email. Read our privacy notice.

Gurleen Kaur, CPA licensed in British Columbia and Washington State · Verify in the CPABC directory or the Washington Board of Accountancy · Read our Google reviews · 15518 103A Ave #10, Surrey, BC V3R 1N7